Investigators have identified a man whose partial remains turned up in McMinn County in 1991, ending a John Doe designation that lasted more than three decades. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation announced that the remains belong to Forest Wayne Loudermilk, a white male originally from North Carolina.
The McMinn County Sheriff’s Office, the University of Tennessee Forensic Anthropology Center and the TBI’s Unidentified Human Remains Initiative worked together on the identification. Detectives and TBI agents now want the public’s help learning what happened to him.
Remains found in 1991
Partial human remains turned up in a residential area of McMinn County on April 10, 1991. Forensic anthropologists first believed they belonged to a black male, likely between 31 and 50 years old.
The Sheriff’s Office and the UT Forensic Anthropology Center tried to identify him with the technology available at the time. They ran out of leads and could not name him.
In 2015, the UT center sent a sample of the remains to the University of Texas Center for Human Identification. Scientists developed a DNA profile and entered it into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) and the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NAMUS). Nothing came of it.
Genetic genealogy breaks the case open
In May 2025, TBI agents helped the Sheriff’s Office and the UT center send a sample to Othram Inc., a private lab in Texas, for forensic genetic genealogy testing. The work came through the TBI’s Unidentified Human Remains DNA Initiative, with funding from the Research Triangle Institute International (RTI).
Othram scientists identified possible relatives. Investigators contacted one of them and obtained a familial DNA standard, which went to the lab for comparison with the unidentified man’s DNA.
The DNA and genealogy results confirmed the remains were those of Loudermilk, whose date of birth was December 8, 1931. Some records list his name as Wayne Forrest Loudermilk or Forest Wayman Loudermilk. His family last saw him around 1980.
Investigators ask for tips and photos
Despite an extensive search, investigators could not find a photograph of Loudermilk. They are asking anyone who has one to come forward.
They also want to hear from anyone who knows who he may have been with before his death. Tips go to the McMinn County Sheriff’s Office at 423-745-5620, Ext. 1928.
“We appreciate our great working relationship with all divisions of TBI, and it’s those relationships that result in successful developments in cases like this,” said McMinn County Sheriff Joe Guy. “We also encourage anyone with information about Mr. Loudermilk to reach out to us and help his family find further peace and closure.”
The source did not say how Loudermilk died. Investigators have not released details about the circumstances of his death.